“Forgiveness is a strange thing. It can sometimes be easier to forgive our enemies than our friends. It can be hardest of all to forgive people we love. Like all of life’s important coping skills, the ability to forgive and the capacity to let go of resentments most likely take root very early in our lives.”
Fred Rogers
“Being angry is like swallowing a spiky and potentially poisonous stone. It can do no good inside of you...poop it out and flush it away”
Nurse Judy
I am not a classically religious person. My friends and family have heard me say that my belief system is simple:
There is ‘more to it than this’, we just don’t get to know exactly what that is
Be kind
So while I am skeptical about an all powerful being with a white beard judging my every action, there is something about the upcoming holidays that has me treat them with a bit of reverence.
Jewish holidays run on a lunar calendar. Some years they feel very early and sometimes quite late. This year, somehow it feels right on time.
This evening, September 11th is the start of the Jewish New Year, Rosh Hashanah. Happy 5787
The message of Rosh Hashanah is one of renewal. Out with the old year (don’t let the door hit you on the way out) and in with the new. We eat apples and honey to usher in a sweet one.
Ten days later Yom Kippur will come along.
The message around Yom Kippur is twofold: forgiveness and atonement
I will start with forgiveness.
I am not saying that you shouldn’t get angry at someone who has done something wrong. By all means, feel those feelings as much as you need to. But then take a moment to do some thinking. When we feel a strong emotion we can ask ourselves what this particular feeling is trying to communicate to us. Perhaps something has been threatened or a boundary has been crossed.
Once you have identified the purpose of the emotion it has done its job. Now it is time to let your head take over.
It might seem like I am going off topic, but bear with me for a moment:
When I was working at Noe Valley Pediatrics, it was not unusual for kids to vomit, snot, poop or bleed on a surface or the floor. People who work with kids know that this is simply part of the job. Bodily secretions are considered biohazards. We had to have a system for dealing with these messes.
Fortunately we had nifty little kits designed for exactly this purpose. The amazing medical assistants who I was lucky enough to work with would spring into action. They would put on some protective equipment and proceed to sprinkle a special substance on the mess. This chemical turned whatever yucky stuff we were dealing with into a gel form that created a blob that was easily cleaned up and disposed of. These clean up kits were a valuable tool.
Anger and grudges directed towards someone are like a biohazard. Those negative feelings can actually impact your health. You need tools for learning how to change something potentially toxic into something more benign and easily dealt with.
One technique that I like is to turn mad into sad. Turn anger into disappointment. Those are potentially heavy feelings, but they are less toxic to you.
What can you add to your own little ‘bio hazard’ kit?
Perhaps talk to a therapist. Meditate. Go to a rage room. See what you can come up with that helps you let go of stuff.
And, there are indeed some things actually feel unforgivable. But what you do with that is up to you. Can you find a way to still love somebody?
Don’t forget to forgive yourself! None of us are perfect and we all have lessons to be learned. You will be amazed how much lighter you can feel when you let go of even some of that negative energy.
Atonement is perhaps more complicated. What constitutes actual atonement? My sister-in-law Barbara and I discussed that in depth while we wandered around Flower Piano this afternoon. Saying a prayer? Giving an apology? Words without inherently recognizing what you have done was wrong, feel pretty empty. Performative action also might not qualify as true atonement.
After a fascinating discussion, we came up with no real resolution and ended up participating in a Neil Young sing along instead.
With the theme of atonement at the heart of it, traditionally between Rosh Hashana and Yom Kippur, there is a lovely ritual called tashlich, where you toss breadcrumbs into a body of water as a symbol of casting off your sins.
I remember one year so long ago (Lauren was probably exactly the same age of my grandson Elliot) I took my young daughters out in a boat on Blue Heron Lake to do our own version and toss bread to the ducks (ducks actually shouldn’t eat bread, but I didn’t know that at the time. I have forgiven myself.)
We did our own little ritual.
“Is there anything you have done that you feel sorry about?”
Lauren went first and did it with a gusto as she tossed piece after piece to the eager ducks. She had an absolute laundry list of confessions.
“This is for the time that I …….
And this is for the time that I……”
She went on for several minutes confessing to all sorts of little misdemeanors that I had been clueless about. Yikes!
Finally she was done. Her conscience was clear.
“Alana, it’s your turn, Is there anything you feel regret about?
“Nope”
“Nothing at all?”
“Nope.”
Okay, well then…..
Alana’s friends might be nodding their heads right now. It is quite possibly accurate.
How you say you are sorry makes a difference.
If you accidentally knocked over a glass of milk, pointing out that it was awfully close to the edge of the table is not an appropriate part of the apology.
“If someone hadn’t left that glass there, this would not have happened” (try again)
“Oops, I should have been more aware of my surroundings, let me help get that cleaned up” (better)
In the same vein, it is important to point out the difference between intent and impact. While good intentions gone awry happen frequently, it is the impact that is what matters. If you said something hurtful, it doesn’t matter all that much if you meant it or not. If it caused pain, make the apology a clean one, don’t muck it up with the defense or reason. Simply be sorry, learn the lesson and try not to repeat.
Parents, caregivers and people who are role models to children - Your kids are watching you! If you can learn to forgive, they will notice. If you learn to admit mistakes and try to do better in the future, they will notice.
As the amazing Mister Rogers noted in the quote at the beginning, these behaviors take root early on.
There is nothing easy about this. Especially these days when it is so easy to be angry at people who are making horrible choices.
I wish that genuinely atoning for something was actually as easy as tossing crumbs into the lake.
Have I completely forgiven the people who stole the catalytic converter out of my 14 year old Honda a few years ago? Perhaps. Knowing that I cursed them with never ending pinworms, bedbugs and head lice took a little of the sting out of it.
Regardless of your faith or religion, I am wishing absolutely everyone a sweet New Year.
Thank you to Taco Cat for being my model this week.







